A UN conference on autonomous weapons ended early Friday with only a minimal consensus after nearly 100 countries pushed for binding restrictions on lethal autonomous weapon systems, but the United States, Russia, Israel, Belarus and Britain blocked a formal mandate for negotiations.
Diplomats at the Geneva conference of 128 states party to the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons could not agree on a concrete mandate to negotiate a legally binding ban on fully autonomous weapons that can select targets and fire without human authorization. Instead, government experts will continue discussions over the next two years to explore possible rules and whether they could eventually lead to a binding treaty.
The conference ended after hours of overnight negotiations in the early morning hours. Russia's resistance to a binding agreement effectively functioned as a veto, since the conference operates by consensus. Russian representatives had also blocked formal proceedings at the start by refusing to accept the agenda and demanding restrictions on speaking rights for the EU and other observers.
Nearly 100 countries had supported rapid negotiations on a legally binding prohibition of fully autonomous, AI-driven weapons that can kill without a human giving the final firing order. The United States, as the world's largest military power and a leader in artificial intelligence development, was among those opposing a concrete mandate for binding negotiations.
Thomas Küchenmeister, speaking for Stop Killer Robots in Germany, criticized the outcome. "The watered-down mandate contains no ambitions to ban autonomous weapons quickly and bindingly and to regulate them comprehensively," he said. "The arms race for weapons increasingly controlled by artificial intelligence continues unabated."
Küchenmeister said that if soldiers have only seconds to verify whether an AI-suggested course of action respects international humanitarian law, meaningful human control becomes nearly impossible. Lethal autonomous weapon systems, or LAWS, are weapons that can independently select and pursue targets and autonomously trigger deadly attacks.
Brazilian Ambassador Frederico Meyer said at the conference that while Russia is often portrayed as the obstacle, "some people hide behind Russia." Beyond the United States, Israel, Belarus and Britain also expressed reservations against committing to a binding treaty. Germany had previously advocated for a legally binding treaty prohibiting fully autonomous systems but signaled during the conference it would accept less to avoid blocking consensus.
Nongovernmental organizations including Stop Killer Robots expressed disappointment with the minimal result. The decision to continue discussions rather than establish binding rules means the development of increasingly AI-controlled weapons will proceed without immediate international legal constraints.