District attorneys from 30 of California's 58 counties asked the state Supreme Court on Monday to stop Gov. Gavin Newsom from commuting the death sentences of all 548 prisoners on the state's death row, arguing he exceeded his authority and ignored the rights of victims' families.
The petition says Newsom acted unlawfully by moving ahead without giving victims "the opportunity to be heard." If carried out, the commutations would be the largest mass commutation of death sentences in U.S. history, UPI reported.
"Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process," the petition says, calling the decision "an abuse of power that must not stand."
"Only this court can stop the governor's disregard of the law," the petitioners wrote, describing the move as an abuse of power.
The filing contrasts a California governor's commutation power with a U.S. president's pardon power, which has no limit other than impeachment. Under state law, when a condemned prisoner applies for commutation, the governor must notify the district attorney in the county where the crime took place, as well as the victims or their families.
Newsom's office argues that requirement does not apply here, because none of the commutations came from a prisoner's application. In an explanatory statement, Newsom said the notification section "does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative to grant clemency absent an application."
His office has said that once it submits the commutations to the Supreme Court, it will notify district attorneys in the counties where the crimes occurred and ask for their help reaching victims' families.
Newsom announced the commutations earlier this month. In a letter to Californians, he wrote that "state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California's values" and called the death penalty system a failure that "cannot be fairly applied and has resulted in the conviction of innocent people."
The Supreme Court must approve commutations for prisoners convicted of more than one felony. Newsom has requested approval for 382 such prisoners and asked the court to give its recommendation by the end of the year, before his term ends, according to UPI. Court representatives have not said how or when the reviews will take place, CalMatters reported.
The challenge has split prosecutors and victims' families. District attorneys in Santa Clara and Contra Costa counties issued statements Monday backing the commutations as costly and ineffective, UPI reported, citing The Guardian. The sisters of Polly Klaas, a 12-year-old girl murdered in 1993, also supported Newsom, while their father, Marc Klaas, joined the petition.
Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019 and later ordered the death chamber at San Quentin dismantled. California has executed 13 people since it reinstated capital punishment in 1978, most recently Clarence Ray Allen in 2006. Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra has pledged to extend the moratorium when he takes office.